Opening the Gates: Hindu-Pagan Alliance

One of the many positive things that came out of PantheaCon 2011 is alliance building between Hindu and Pagan communities. See the excellent guest post at The Wild Hunt on this by Mihir Meghani, M.D.; Board Member & Co-Founder of the Hindu American Foundation ( However one feels about the concept of Proto-Indo-European, there are many commonalities among European mythologies and indigenous religious systems and those of India. Alwyn Rees and Brinley Rees showed many parallels between Irish and Hindu myth and deities in their classic work Celtic Heritage (perhaps over-doing it according to some commentators) from the similarities between ‘gods of the dead’ Yama and Donn to the primal goddesses Danu of both Ireland and Vedic India.. So Celtic Recconstructionism and Druidism among others make natural allies with that rich world known as Hinduism.

Ganesha riding his vehicle, 1816

For those who live in urban spaces in the western world signs of the Indian Diaspora, particularly in the public visibility of statues of Hindu deities, are common. One of the most visible, and seen in many shop windows ,is Ganesha. The lord of obstacles—and their removal— has been said to have become a ‘global’ god, journeying out from the precincts of Hinduism and approaching people of many spiritual paths (and none). It seems he is an ambassador of Hinduism. Westerners have actuallly been fascinated by Ganesha for a long time; Richard Payne Knight’s A Discourse on the Worship of Priapus, and its connection with the mystic Theology of the Ancients included a discussion of the elephant-headed god in 1786. Phil Hine at has a lot of interesting things to say about Ganesha, both historically and in terms of practice:

One of Ganesha’s roles is gatekeeper. A magnificent Ganesha statue stands at the entrance to the floor that houses the Indian collection of the Asian Art Museum (which was formed originally to house the collection of Avery Brundage, a once Olympic athlete and president of the International Olympic Committee from 1952 to 1972) in San Francisco. The museum is full of sacred art, including a wonderful collection of Shivaite art and many paintings and sculptures of Ganesha Yet the thirteenth century Ganesha at the top of the escalator is the only sculpture where sanctity is emphasized. Visitors can offer coins, etc. Inside the space seems too small for the artworks displayed. I have talked to Indians currently residing in San Francisco who were impressed with all of the Indian art exhibited in the permanent collection, but wished for more respectful lighting and the possibility of simple offerings like incense and flowers to be placed in front of the various deity statues. Many museums have come a long way from when they were basically repositories of colonial loot, but how to respectfully display sacred art remains a complicated question. Certainly, sacred art can be one of the best portals into a tradition.

May Lord Ganesha help open the ways for Hindu-Pagan alliance in the world!

“Victory to Ganesha, who, when dancing, makes a shower of stars, resembling a rain of flowers, fall from the sky, by a blow of his trunk!” (From C.H. Tawney’s 1880-1884 translation of Somadeva’s eleventh-century Ocean of Streams of Story)


One thought on “Opening the Gates: Hindu-Pagan Alliance

  1. The respectful display of sacred art is a big question–and not just for Hinduism, I think.

    Tons of things that folks like you and I love and revere, and to which we would offer devotions if allowed to, still exist only because they are in museums; and yet, museum-keepers don’t see them that way, and don’t want a bunch of weirdos doing devotions in front of their “exhibits.”

    On the one hand, the wranglings in the U.K. over reburial of the pre-Christian dead as ancestors and the upset over their display or storage in museums is understandable, but also has caused more of a scene than done anything useful; however, dead people are not the only things of value and importance for pagans, and no one has really addressed this issue in terms of the museums that now “own” a lot of sacred objects. (The Vatican comes to mind in our own particular case…but, they’re not the only ones…)

    Difficult matters, certainly…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s